FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

 

AT A GLANCE

 

WHO IS OCEANEOS?

The Oceaneos Marine Research Foundation is a non-profit research organization based in Vancouver (BC), Canada developing technology to address the critical problem of global fishery and marine ecosystem collapse as a result of climate change. With a strong international team of engineers and scientist in the fields of oceanography and marine biology, we have the mission to revitalize the oceans and restore fisheries through a combination of sustainable practices, marine sanctuaries and the application of Ocean Seeding in depleted areas of the ocean.

Learn more

 

WHAT DOES OCEANEOS DO?

Oceaneos engages in the scientific research and development of Ocean Seeding: a method that rehabilitates marine ecosystems and increases wild fish populations at a local scale through ocean fertilization. Current projections suggest that by 2050 oceans will be depleted and the fishery industry will cease to exist. This is already a major disaster for billions of people that are directly dependent on the oceans and fish as their main source of protein and income. Oceaneos implements Ocean Seeding projects in close collaboration with governments, fishery industry, and universities.
Read our Code of Conduct.

 

WITH WHICH ORGANIZATIONS DOES OCEANEOS COLLABORATE?

Conducting rigorous scientific research requires the interplay of several active players, as well as carefully following regional and international regulations on Ocean Seeding project setup. To ensure efficient, sustainable and transparent project development Oceaneos partners with federal and local GOVERNMENT agencies, artisanal and commercial fisheries, NGO’s and experts in the field of ocean and biological sciences from UNIVERSITIES around the world.

 

WHAT IS OCEAN FERTILIZATION?

Ocean fertilization is a natural process, which happens when the physical forces of global winds and coastal upwelling currents, as well as volcanic activity, which transfer mineral nutrients, like iron, from the earth’s crust into the ocean. Worldwide, winds transport about 10 billion kilograms of dust on any given day, which is roughly equivalent to the mass of three supertanker ships. In areas that are low in nutrients, this causes rapid blooms of phytoplankton, which in turn provides food for the whole marine ecosystem. Ocean fertilization can be PURPOSELY INDUCED, by adding missing nutrients like iron to areas in the open ocean to trigger controlled plankton blooms. This can turn a declining ocean environment into a teeming, complex web of marine life.

Learn more.

 

GLOBAL WINDS

These carry iron dust from deserts to the ocean; triggering phytoplankton blooms in the upper water layers when they are deposited. They can also push upper oceanic layers away from the shoreline, creating flow from deeper waters that surface as upwelling currents.

OIF process

 

UPWELLING CURRENTS

They occur when winds blow the upper layers of the ocean off the coast, forcing water from deeper, colder and nutrient-rich layers to move upwards and replace the displaced waters. This triggers phytoplankton blooms when these nutrients meet the algae and sunlight of the upper layers.

OIF process

 

VOLCANOES

These work in the same way as global winds, in terms of particles in the wind that settle in the oceanic surface, but are much more dramatic and short-lived, given that they come from volcanic eruptions. The iron-rich ashes quickly falls and mixes with the upper ocean layers, triggering record-size phytoplankton blooms.

OIF process

 

ARE OCEAN FERTILIZATION AND OCEAN SEEDING THE SAME?

While ocean fertilization is a naturally occurring process that has been at the center of ocean-based carbon dioxide (CO2) sequestration schemes, Ocean Seeding is the specific application of ocean fertilization to revitalize local marine ecosystems which in turn recover the depleted marine ecology and fish stocks.

 

HOW DOES OCEAN SEEDING WORK?

Ocean Seeding aims to trigger the growth of a plankton bloom at a small, local scale in environmentally barren areas of the ocean within known migration routes of fish populations. The induced plankton bloom provides juvenile fish with food at a critical time of their development, dramatically enhancing their chance of survival resulting in a decrease in population mortality. It’s a sustainable and effective intervention that provides for them till adulthood, where they can be harvested with less risk of overfishing or damage to the ecosystem.

 

WHERE ARE OCEAN SEEDING PROJECT EXECUTED?

Project locations are carefully selected for an optimal benefit to the local ecosystem and fish populations. First, an area is chosen based on intersections with known migration routes or nurseries of economically important fish. Second, High Nutrient, Low Chlorophyll (HNLC) zones are identified that are ripe for iron incorporation, since they represent an iron-limited ecosystem missing a vital nutrient, so low concentrations strategically placed can rapidly revitalize the whole ecological system.
Learn more.

 

HOW CLOSELY DOES OCEAN SEEDING COMPARE TO THE NATURAL PROCESS?

The natural process of ocean fertilization has been ongoing on for billions of years, where global winds, volcanoes, and current upwellings deposit dust containing key nutrients, like iron, in the ocean that in turn trigger the growth of plankton. The difference with Ocean Seeding is its implementation: it mimics the natural process but within a carefully selected area in the open ocean, at the right time of juvenile fish development or when migrating fish are passing through. Ocean Seeding is tailored to revitalize fish populations, so its execution is limited to small scale areas that need immediate ecological restoration, where the natural conditions cannot support ecosystems anymore due to the effects of climate change and human impact.

 

IS OCEAN SEEDING GEOENGINEERING?

Geoengineering includes deliberate technological methods aimed to counter climate change on a global scale; carbon sequestration being among these schemes. Oceaneos’ application of ocean fertilization is not geoengineering. Oceaneos conducts Ocean Seeding in small-scale, scientifically controlled projects, aimed to enhance fish stock locally and revitalize marine ecosystems that have been damaged and depleted by climate change, pollution, and overfishing.
Read our Code of Conduct.

 

HOW MUCH IRON IS USED IN AN OCEAN SEEDING PROJECT?

For Ocean Seeding projects, only very low quantities of iron are required to achieve the desired fertilization effects. It takes a few weeks to deposit 10 to 100 tons of iron in a ratio of about 1 cup of iron powder per hectare open ocean. The effects of ecosystem revitalization and population recovery are measured over the course of approximately 18 months.

 

 

IS OCEAN FERTILIZATION ALLOWED?

Ocean Seeding projects are executed within the 200 mile Exclusive Economic Zone of a nation require environmental permits issued by that nation. Furthermore, ocean fertilization in the high seas is regulated through the London Convention, a regulation implemented by the United Nations and signed by 87 countries. Under this regulation, Ocean fertilization projects for scientific purposes need to be approved by the International Maritime Organization (IMO). Oceaneos only implements Ocean Seeding projects after obtaining the required environmental permits and in close collaboration with government and fishery industry.
Learn more.

 

CAN OCEAN FERTILIZATION BE USED TO SEQUESTER CARBON DIOXIDE (CO2)?

The idea to use ocean fertilization to capture carbon dioxide is based on the natural process in which plankton consumes CO2 when it grows. When plankton dies and sinks to the bottom of the ocean, the absorbed CO2 can be stored for extended periods of time and may even become the next Dover cliffs or even petroleum oil. Several scientific institutions are currently researching the topic, and the long-term carbon sequestration effects are being still debated. Oceaneos has not involved in carbon dioxide (CO2) sequestration schemes or carbon accounting.
Learn more.

 

DOES OCEANEOS USE OCEAN FERTILIZATION FOR CARBON SEQUESTRATION?

No. Oceaneos is not involved in carbon dioxide (CO2) sequestration schemes or carbon accounting. Oceaneos’ application of ocean fertilization use Ocean Seeding to enhance fisheries and revitalize marine ecosystems that have been damaged by climate change, pollution, and unsustainable harvest methods.

 

ECOSYSTEM

 

WHAT IS PHYTOPLANKTON?

Phytoplankton are microscopic, photosynthetic organisms that float on the top layers of the ocean to harness sunlight and convert it to organic matter. Phytoplankton are the foundation of the marine ecosystem, and for billions of years they reshaped the planet and the atmosphere; giving rise to air-breathing organisms, ancestors to animals like us. There are two main types. On one hand, the PROKARYOTES, or single cells without internal compartments, of which cyanobacteria are the most important subgroup, have been terraforming the planet and its ecosystems for billions of years. On the other hand, the more derived eukaryotes include the diverse diatoms, which are shelled organisms with geometric silica cases that drift with currents and the dinoflagellates, which are less common, but actively move through the water column. Phytoplankton are responsible for some of the bioluminescence we see in the ocean and a broad range of compounds, including toxins. Some are only photosynthetic, while some can actively hunt for other organisms and even other phytoplankton.
Learn more.

 

WHAT ARE RED TIDES?

Typically, red tides are rampant blooms of coastal dinoflagellates, a type of plankton, which are preyed upon by each other and by larger organisms in the food chain. To protect themselves, these microscopic shelled organisms release toxins, which is the primary cause of what we humans call shellfish poisoning, but it affects all levels of marine life in different ways. Other coastal species of plankton are also capable of releasing toxins. Shorelines are the perfect scenario for red tides, with abundant predation and nutrients, they happen seasonally and die off after a couple of months; usually with serious adverse effects to local coastal organisms at their peak of activity. Red tides do not happen in the open ocean, as the environmental and ecological conditions do not support their formation.
Learn more.

 

WHAT IS CAUSING GLOBAL FISH STOCKS TO DECLINE?

The ocean is an unfathomably vast environment, the largest and oldest ecosystem known. It’s governed by an incredibly complex interplay of mechanisms, many of which have experienced sudden and drastic changes due to human impact, which has been dramatic given how recent they are compared to the planet’s history. The oceans are changing due to some interrelated factors at local, regional and global scales. OCEAN WARMING sharpens the differences in surface layers and inhibits water mixing that is vital for ocean ecology. ACIDIFICATION happens due to the diffusion of carbon dioxide into the water, which lowers the pH, hindering important chemistry some organisms need to survive, as well as reducing oxygen levels at an alarming rate. DEOXYGENATION happens when large plankton blooms occur in the same coastal area for extended periods of time; they die off and fall into the seafloor where decomposition uses up oxygen. This typically occurs near shore where nutrients are abundant either as a result of pollution or natural causes such as upwelling. POLLUTION has direct effects on ecosystems, killing wildlife through toxins and contamination, including many economically important species. OVERFISHING is a management problem; the unsustainable overharvest of species that does not allow for populations to recover fast enough from the little numbers left behind. However, a lesser-known and crucial factor in the fish stock decline is PLANKTON CHANGE in either timing and biomass as plankton adapts to changing conditions. Oceanic phytoplankton is arguably the most important group of organisms on Earth. They are the food source of the marine ecosystem, are responsible for more than half of the planet’s biomass production and more than 70% of the oxygen we breathe. But climate change is changing this. Fish are dying as a consequence, and this is a symptom of a much larger, urgent problem. We need immediate term solutions, to establish sustainable fishing practices that ensure food security; median term solutions, to fix the ecosystems and mitigate human-driven ecological decay; and long term solutions, to restore our planet back to health.
Learn more.

 

WHAT IS SUSTAINABLE FISHING?

It’s a method that ensures long term fish stock harvest without compromising the health and stability of economically important marine populations. Its an environmentally healthy practice that ensures food security in the present and into the future.
Learn more.

 

DOES OCEAN SEEDING ALTER THE FOOD CHAIN?

Yes, Ocean Seeding attempts to restore the natural marine food chain which has been altered by climate change, pollution, overfishing or a combination of all three.

 

RISKS

 

WHAT ARE THE RISKS OF OCEAN FERTILIZATION?

Ecological systems are incredibly complex, and even though they can be measured and understood, there are many possible outcomes to shifts in starting conditions. Among them three are often mentioned: RED TIDES (read more: Does ocean fertilization create red tides?), DEAD ZONES (read more: Does ocean fertilization create dead zones?), and TOXICITY (read more: Does ocean fertilization make the ocean toxic?). Note that these risks can be prevented or mitigated through careful project location, timing, and implementation.The largest environmental risk posed by ocean fertilization experimentation is simply a lack of knowledge.
Learn more.

 

DOES OCEAN FERTILIZATION CREATE RED TIDES?

Red tides are only known to occur in COASTAL AREAS where the environmental, biodiversity and predation conditions arise that prompt some plankton types to defend themselves by releasing toxins. Ocean fertilization projects take place in the OPEN OCEAN, typically more than 100 km offshore, where the plankton species and environmental conditions make it very unlikely for red tides to occur. Since the 1990s more than twelve ocean fertilization projects have been executed on the open ocean, and none of them resulted in a red tide. In fact, red tides or other harmful algal blooms have never been observed in the deep ocean. To mitigate any risk from red tides, water samples are taken before and during an Ocean Seeding project and tested for toxic plankton species.

 

DOES OCEAN FERTILIZATION CREATE DEAD ZONES?

Iron ocean fertilization is a natural process that has been going on for billions of years through iron-rich dust deposits by global winds and volcanoes or upwelling from the ocean bottom triggering plankton blooms. Once the bloom runs its course the organic material sinks, where bacteria decompose it. This process consumes oxygen which, if depleted, creates a DEAD ZONE for remaining or migrating organisms. This can happen in COASTAL areas and NUTRIENT RICH zones, where the decomposing bacteria are close to the surface. Ocean fertilization projects are executed in the open ocean where dead zones are not known to happen, since the seafloor is so far away from the sunlit surface layers that plankton does not interact with the seafloor ecosystem, unlike in shallower areas or the coasts.

 

DOES OCEAN FERTILIZATION MAKE THE OCEAN TOXIC?

Iron is the 4th most abundant element in the earth’s crust and a major factor in the metabolic mechanisms in living cells. This is why some many people take iron supplements to be healthy; and as with all supplements, toxicity is related to dose and dosage. Iron is very beneficial, indeed required for life, while toxic in massive quantities. Low nutrients seawater contains low concentrations of iron of approximately 1 to 10 parts per trillion. Ocean Seeding mimics the natural ocean fertilization process and only deposits comparable or less than the natural occurring amounts of iron; ensuring a natural bloom cycle. No previous ocean fertilization experiments have reported toxicity from the iron or the emergence of secondary toxins from plankton species, nor have these effects ever been reported in the deep ocean.

 

DOES OCEAN FERTILIZATION GENERATE NUTRIENT LOSS?

One of the key features of a selected project location is the presence of a HIGH NUTRIENT, LOW CHLOROPHYLL (HNLC) zone, regions with an excess of nutrients and low photosynthesis. The addition of iron does not remove nutrients; it only allows plankton species to take advantage of them; ocean fertilization only adds to the existing productivity. The high presence of every other nutrient is not dependent on iron.

 

DOES OCEAN FERTILIZATION CREATE BIODIVERSITY SHIFTS?

Naturally occurring blooms have characteristic changes in overall species composition compared to non-bloom conditions. Usually, smaller phytoplankton species dominate the background plankton groups in deep HNLC oceans. However, during a bloom, larger species take over for a short while. These are temporal changes and the population’s shift back to previous conditions when the bloom is over. One of the reasons blooms revitalizes whole ecosystems is the temporal shift in species richness and biomass, which many organisms benefit from.

 

DOES OCEAN FERTILIZATION GENERATE CLIMATE ACTIVE GASES?

While nitrous oxide (N2O) and dimethylsulfide (DMS) are products of normal oceanic biological metabolism, their production is highly dependent on geographical location, where more tropical regions are prone to releasing more of these gasses while they are almost inexistent in Northern and Southern waters. Ocean Seeding projects are concerned with ecosystem revitalization and not carbon sequestration, where these gasses must be accounted for. In ecological terms, the cycling of these gasses would have an expected net effect, just like in natural conditions.

 

TECHNOLOGY

 

HOW DO YOU ENSURE ONLY BENEFICIAL ALGAE BLOOM?

The process of site selection for a project is very strict; the location must have specific requirements for Ocean Seeding to work. During the early setup phases, a phytoplankton analysis is conducted of the targeted area; if a certain amount of potentially harmful species are detected the site is deemed unfit for ocean fertilization, so no procedure is executed.

 

HOW IS THE IRON DEPLOYED INTO THE OCEAN?

The iron is added from the propeller wash of a research vessel, which mixes the iron with the upper layers of the ocean to ensure its suspension. Depending on the type of iron it may be dissolved or suspended before being added to the prop wash. Multiple simultaneous ships cover more area and make the procedure more efficient by reducing the time and synchronizing deployment. Phytoplankton can readily take advantage of the iron mixed in the upper layers where sunlight is abundant; it is rapidly uptaken, and an ecosystem bloom follows within days.

 

PROJECTS AND EXPERIMENTS

 

HOW MANY OCEAN FERTILIZATION PROJECTS HAVE BEEN EXECUTED SO FAR?

Since the proposal of the process in the early 1990s by oceanographer John Martin, there have been twelve major publicly funded small-scale experimental trials, which have shown that the addition of iron can stimulate large blooms of phytoplankton. None of the experiments created negative environmental effects. The success of the technology has sparked interest on its multiple applications, the most promising of which is ecosystem revitalization.

OIF process

OIF process

 

 

IS OCEANEOS RELATED TO THE 2012 OCEAN FERTILIZATION AT THE HAIDA GWAII ARCHIPELAGO?

Since the 1990s, more than twelve ocean fertilization experiments have been conducted by different research groups. The last project executed in 2012 off the coast of Haida Gwaii by HSRC. Oceaneos uses data from all previous ocean fertilization projects including the Haida Gwaii project, and works with some of the scientists involved, but it does not have direct ties to HSRC.